
The Collapse of Neutrality and the Search for a New Journalism -
The Collapse of Neutrality and the Search for a New Journalism -: The Crisis of Legacy Media Abstract The crisis of legacy media in the West is commonly attributed to declining public trust, political polarization, misinformation, and the rise of alternative media. This article argues that these developments are symptoms of a deeper crisis: the erosion of the epistemological legitimacy of Western journalism and its longstanding claim that neutrality provides the foundation for objectivity. It examines how editorial choices concerning language, event selection, coverage priorities, and omission inevitably shape the production of news, often reproducing the political assumptions and institutional preferences of the environments in which media organizations operate. The article challenges the tendency to present these choices as neutral professional conventions and argues that institutional reputation and claims of independence are insufficient measures of journalistic credibility. In their place, it proposes the Principle of Editorial Integrity, according to which credibility should be assessed through the demonstrable consistency between an institution’s declared principles, editorial practices, and published record. The principle encompasses five interconnected dimensions: transparency, evidentiary integrity, consistency, completeness, and accountability. Drawing on a systems perspective, the article further conceptualizes media organizations as systems whose credibility must be evaluated not merely through individual publications but through the relationship between their institutional commitments, editorial processes, outputs, and accumulated consequences over time. It identifies digital archives and comparative analysis as increasingly accessible instruments for examining institutional performance. With particular attention to the erosion of universal human rights standards through selective political application, the article argues for a journalism grounded in transparent commitments, evidentiary rigor, and consistent principles. It concludes that the future of credible journalism depends not on the unattainable absence of perspective but on the integrity with which media institutions acknowledge, apply, and remain accountable to their principles... read more
